So you think you need a Phase I?

 

Due Diligence and the Process -

Contributed by Gene Joanen, CEO & Senior Scientist, Balance Consulting, Inc.

With 38 years of hands-on experience as an environmental scientist and program manager, I’ve seen how critical environmental site assessments (ESAs) are to smart decision-making. Whether you’re buying land, redeveloping a property, or launching a construction project, an ESA isn’t just a box to check—it’s your roadmap to understanding what’s beneath the surface. At Balance Consulting, Inc. (BCI), we’ve guided clients worldwide through this process, from oilfields in Iraq to coastal ports in Senegal, and right here in New Orleans, where I served as State Commissioner for SELFPA-East.

What’s a Phase I?

An ESA is a practical investigation to uncover potential environmental risks tied to a property. It’s split into three key stages: Phase I, Phase II, and Remedial Investigation and Planning. Think of it as a tool to manage liability, not just a regulatory hoop to jump through. It’s about knowing what you’re dealing with—whether it’s contaminated soil, groundwater issues, or something else—so you can weigh the risks and move forward with confidence.

A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) is a non-invasive investigation that identifies potential environmental risks on a property by reviewing its history, regulatory records, and current condition, while All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) is a federal standard under CERCLA that ensures a thorough Phase I process to qualify for liability protections. These tools are invaluable for real estate transactions, audits, mergers, and insurance underwriting, helping buyers, sellers, and investors assess risks, secure financing, or negotiate terms. However, Phase I ESAs and AAI aren’t one-size-fits-all—they can be tailored to focus on specific concerns like industrial pasts or future redevelopment plans, varying in scope based on client needs. They’re a snapshot of one moment, not a full picture, and they do not include hidden or future issues. Competent reviews look beyond the report, weighing past uses, current activities, and potential future risks to provide a fuller understanding.

What it is not: 

A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) and All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) are distinct from National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) studies and Property Condition Assessments (PCAs), serving different purposes in the due diligence landscape. A Phase I ESA and AAI target potential environmental contamination risks—think soil or groundwater issues tied to a site’s history—offering a tailored snapshot for transactions, audits, mergers, or insurance, though they don’t capture everything and require past, present, and future use analysis. In contrast, NEPA studies are broader, federally mandated environmental reviews for projects involving government action, assessing impacts on ecosystems, air quality, and communities to ensure sustainable decision-making. PCAs, meanwhile, zero in on a property’s physical state—evaluating structural integrity, mechanical systems, and maintenance needs—without touching environmental concerns. At Balance Consulting, Inc., we’ve got you covered across the board: with 38 years of expertise, we deliver customized Phase I ESAs, NEPA studies for regulatory compliance, and PCAs to keep your property’s condition in check, all under one roof.

Phase I: The First Look

We start with a Phase I ESA, a non-invasive deep dive into the property’s past and present. I’ve led countless Phase I projects, from abandoned industrial sites to active oil and gas facilities. Here’s what we do:

• Dig into History: We scour old records, aerial photos, and maps. Was it a gas station? A factory? That’s where risks often hide.
• Check the Paper Trail: We review environmental databases—not to appease regulators, but to spot red flags that could affect your bottom line.
• Walk the Site: I’ve personally inspected sites globally, looking for telltale signs like stained soil or odd smells.
• Talk to People: Owners, tenants, and managers often know things records don’t show.

The goal? Spot Recognized Environmental Conditions (RECs)—hints of trouble. If it’s clean, you might stop here. If not, we roll up our sleeves for Phase II.

Phase II: Getting Dirty

When Phase I raises concerns, Phase II gets specific. This is where my team at BCI—backed by my experience as a drone pilot and groundwater specialist—takes samples to confirm what’s there. We’ve tackled everything from heavy metals at old manufacturing sites to PCE from former dry cleaners. Here’s the drill:

• Soil Testing: We dig in to check for hydrocarbons, metals, or pesticides.
• Groundwater Sampling: With my Louisiana contractor’s license in groundwater monitoring, I’ve overseen wells that reveal what’s leaching below.
• Air Checks: If vapors are a risk, we test that too—especially for buildings over tainted ground.

Phase II gives you hard data and is intrusive in nature: Is there contamination? How bad is it? That’s the foundation for deciding what’s an acceptable risk—or what needs fixing.

Remedial Investigation and Planning: Fixing What’s Broken

If Phase II confirms trouble, we shift to Remedial Investigation. I’ve led these efforts on National Priority List sites and Formerly Used Defense Sites, mapping out contamination and assessing its impact. We figure out:

• How Far It Spreads: Horizontally, vertically—where’s it going?
• What Caused It: Knowing the source guides the fix.
• What’s the Risk: To people, to the environment, to your project.

Then we craft a Remediation Plan. I’ve designed solutions like soil excavation, groundwater treatment systems, and vapor barriers—practical fixes that work. We monitor the process, document it, and get you to closure. It’s not about regulatory gold stars; it’s about making the site usable and insurable.

Why ESAs Matter

Here’s the common-sense take:

• Risk You Can Handle: An ESA flags liabilities early. You can negotiate cleanup costs or walk away before you’re stuck. I’ve seen it save clients millions.
• Insurance Over Regs: Banks and investors care about risk, not just compliance certificates. My work with specialty risk insurance—like integrating drone data for disaster claims—gives them confidence.
• Practical Protection: Contamination isn’t just a legal issue—it’s a health and value issue. Fix it right, and you’re covered.
• Boosting Value: A site with a clean slate (or a managed one) sells better. I’ve seen it firsthand with port and rail projects.

A Real-World Example

Picture this: You’re eyeing an old industrial lot for a mixed-use development. A Phase I finds it housed radiation storage decades ago. Phase II—confirms a limited area of impact with radionuclides in the soil. We remediate it, document it, and now you’ve got a site that’s safe, marketable, and insurable. That’s how BCI turns risks into opportunities.

We do the remediation too.

Turnkey Expertise You Can Trust

BCI Remediation Group, part of Balance Consulting Inc., brings years of know-how to environmental cleanup. From soil and groundwater to waste and marine challenges, we handle it all—anywhere from the Gulf Coast to global sites. Licensed across multiple states and equipped for turnkey projects, we’re the partner you need to get the job done right. Contact us at contact@balanceconsultinginc.com or visit www.balanceconsultinginc.com.

Diverse Solutions, One Team
Need a remediation crew that can do it all? BCI Remediation Group excels in turnkey environmental projects—soil, water, waste, you name it. With 38 years of experience spanning oil and gas, mining, and industrial sectors, we blend cutting-edge tech with a worldwide reach. Based in Folsom, LA, we’re ready 24/7. Call 866-278-5321 or check us out at www.balanceconsultinginc.com.

Your Cleanup, Our Commitment
BCI Remediation Group turns complex cleanups into seamless solutions. With nearly four decades tackling groundwater, soil, and industrial waste across the Gulf and beyond, we’re built for turnkey success. Safety, expertise, and a global perspective—that’s what we bring to every project. Reach us at 985-327-9645 or www.balanceconsultinginc.com.

Why Trust BCI?

This isn’t textbook stuff—it’s what I’ve lived for nearly four decades. From designing mobile labs for Chevron to pioneering alligator nesting algorithms with drones, I bring real-world know-how. My team and I don’t just assess; we solve—drawing on my ASTM voting roles, Louisiana contractor licenses, and global project experience.

Let’s Talk About Your Project

If you’re facing a land deal, redevelopment, or construction, reach out to me at gene@balanceconsultinginc.com. At BCI, we tailor ESAs to your needs—Phase I through remediation—focusing on practical outcomes, not regulatory checklists. With my background in disaster response (think post-storm drone fleets) and environmental tech, we’ll help you manage risks, secure insurance, and keep banks and investors happy.

An ESA isn’t just due diligence—it’s your edge. Let’s make sure your next move is a smart one. 

Navigating the Murky Waters of Foreign Ballast Water in Louisiana Ports: A Deep Dive Part 1

Part 1: Navigating the Murky Waters of Foreign Ballast Water in Louisiana Ports

Introduction: A Hidden Challenge in Plain Sight

If you’ve ever watched a massive cargo ship glide into the Port of New Orleans, you might not think twice about the water sloshing around in its ballast tanks. That water, often scooped up from distant ports across the globe, keeps the vessel stable during its journey. But here’s the catch: it’s not just water. It’s a potential stew of invasive species—microbes, algae, even small fish—that could wreak havoc on Louisiana’s fragile ecosystems if dumped unchecked. For decades, regulators, ship operators, and environmentalists have wrestled with how to manage this "foreign ballast water." Today, the problem persists, tangled in aging treatment systems, a shrinking pool of testing labs, and a regulatory framework that’s struggling to keep pace. So, what’s the story behind this watery dilemma, and where do we go from here?

A Brief History: From Testing to Treatment

Back in the 1990s and early 2000s, the rules were straightforward but labor-intensive. Ships arriving in U.S. ports, including Louisiana, had to test their ballast water before discharge to prove it had been biofouled—essentially, treated to kill off any hitchhiking organisms. This meant collecting samples, sending them to labs, and waiting for results to confirm compliance with federal and state regulations. The process was slow, costly, and reliant on a network of commercial laboratories with the bench space and expertise to handle broad-spectrum testing.

Then came a game-changer: onboard ballast water treatment systems (BWTS). By the mid-2000s, companies began marketing these systems as a solution—devices that could zap, filter, or chemically neutralize invasive species right on the ship. The promise was simple: no more waiting for lab results, just treat and discharge. The International Maritime Organization’s (IMO) Ballast Water Management (BWM) Convention, adopted in 2004 and enforced globally since 2017, pushed this shift further, setting strict discharge standards (known as D-2). The U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) followed suit, implementing its own regulations in 2012, requiring treatment systems to be type-approved and phasing out the older practice of ballast water exchange (flushing tanks mid-ocean).

For a while, it seemed like problem solved. Ships retrofitted with BWTS could sail into ports like New Orleans, treat their water, and discharge legally—assuming the systems worked. But here’s where the cracks started to show.

The Current Mess: Aging Systems and Vanishing Labs

Fast forward to 2025, and the reality is messier than the marketing brochures promised. Many of those treatment systems installed 10–15 years ago are still in use, chugging along on ships that visit Louisiana ports repeatedly. Problem is, they’re not always up to snuff. Maintenance lags, upgrades are rare, and some systems are outright failing. The USCG, tasked with enforcing ballast water rules, isn’t fooled—they know untreated foreign ballast water can’t be dumped into U.S. waters without proof of compliance. But proving compliance has hit a wall.

When BWTS became the norm, the demand for lab testing plummeted. Commercial labs, once bustling with ballast water samples, shifted their focus elsewhere. Bench space dried up, and expertise faded. Today, if a ship’s treatment system fails—or if there’s doubt about its effectiveness—there’s almost nowhere to turn for the broad-spectrum testing once required. Even worse, the labs that remain often lack the specific permits to handle foreign ballast water samples under Louisiana’s stringent Louisiana Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (LPDES) program, overseen by the LDEQ.

Gene Joanen of BCI: “I’d love to hear from a port official or ship operator here. What do they do when a treatment system fails? Are they scrambling to find a lab, or is there another workaround?”

Regulatory Landscape: LDEQ, EPA, and the USCG in 2025

So, where do the LDEQ and EPA stand on this in 2025? The LDEQ, which has managed the state’s water discharge permitting since taking over the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) in 1996, works in tandem with the EPA to enforce water quality standards. Ballast water falls under this umbrella, but it’s a unique beast—regulated primarily by the USCG under federal law, with states like Louisiana ensuring local compliance through LPDES permits.

As of March 24, 2025, there’s no public indication of a major policy shift from the LDEQ or EPA specifically targeting ballast water testing shortages. However, the LDEQ’s 2024 Integrated Report (approved by the EPA in July 2024) highlights ongoing efforts to monitor and protect Louisiana’s waterbodies. Could this signal a future push for more lab capacity? Possibly, but nothing’s concrete yet. The USCG, meanwhile, remains firm: no proof of treatment, no discharge. Ships without functioning BWTS or verifiable test results are stuck.

What Happens Now? Ships’ Stopgap Solutions

With failing systems and no labs to back them up, what are ships doing with their foreign ballast water? Several options emerge, none ideal:

1. Back to Sea: Some vessels sail out beyond U.S. territorial waters (typically 12 nautical miles) and dump in areas deemed “nonsensitive.” This complies with USCG rules if done far enough out, but it’s a fuel-burning hassle and doesn’t address the global invasive species problem.
2. Alternative Ports: Ships might offload ballast water at ports with reception facilities—land-based plants that treat and dispose of it. Problem is, New Orleans and most Louisiana ports don’t have these. Nearby Gulf Coast ports like Houston might, but that’s a detour few want to take.
3. Hold It: Some ships simply retain their ballast water, avoiding discharge entirely. This can mess with stability and cargo operations, making it a last resort.

Gene Joanen says: “A ship captain or logistics expert could shed light here. How often do they reroute or hold water? Real stories would punch this up.”

The Future: Should Louisiana Step Up?

Looking ahead, the foreign ballast water challenge isn’t going away. Invasive species like zebra mussels and Asian carp still threaten the Gulf Coast, and climate change could make Louisiana’s waters even more vulnerable. So, what’s next?

• Lab Revival: Could Louisiana invest in accredited labs to handle ballast water testing? It’d fill a gap, but who pays—taxpayers, shippers, or port authorities? And would it just prop up an outdated system when treatment tech should be the focus?
• Local Treatment Facilities: Building reception facilities at ports like New Orleans could offload the burden from ships. It’s pricey, though, and requires coordination between state, federal, and private players.
• Tech Push: The real fix might be pushing shipowners to upgrade BWTS. Incentives or stricter enforcement could drive this, but it’s a slow grind—retrofits aren’t cheap.

Gene Joanen says: “An LDEQ rep or environmental scientist could weigh in on feasibility. Are there talks about facilities or lab support in 2025?”

Conclusion: Time to Clear the Waters

Foreign ballast water is a sneaky problem—out of sight until it’s too late. Louisiana’s ports, vital to global trade, are caught in a bind: old systems, scarce testing, and a regulatory patchwork that’s tough to navigate. For now, ships limp along with workarounds, but the clock’s ticking. Whether it’s reviving labs, building treatment plants, or forcing tech upgrades, something’s got to give.

Drop your thoughts below, and stay tuned as we dig deeper.

Optimal Data Flow in Harsh Environments

 

A Day in the Life of Gene Joanen with the Ultimate AI Agent

6:00 AM CST – Morning Briefing at Dronetech Solutions USA HQ

You wake up in your home office in Houston, Texas, the heart of your operations. Your day begins with a cup of coffee and a glance at your smart tablet, where your AI agent—let’s call it OptiSynth—has already compiled a morning briefing. OptiSynth isn’t just a tool; it’s a dedicated program-level intelligence designed to oversee your global fleets, manage data streams, and assist your team while presenting actionable insights to stakeholders in real-time.

The morning report highlights:

• Ongoing block cave operations in a copper mine in Arizona, where fracturing data from draw bells and draw points suggests potential instability in a tunnel segment.
• Ambient air quality and radioactive background levels in a Greenland rare-earth mineral mining site, were flagged for slight anomalies overnight.
• An oil spill was detected in the Gulf, with drones already deployed to track its spread.
• Pipeline monitoring along a 500-mile stretch in Alaska, with a small pressure anomaly detected in a subsurface valve.
• Subsurface conditions near an oil rig off Louisiana, where currents and silting patterns indicate a need for canal dredging in New Orleans.

OptiSynth has cross-referenced these data points with historical patterns, predictive models, and team schedules, prioritizing tasks for your fleet and personnel. It’s also flagged maintenance updates for a sea drone off the Gulf that’s nearing 500 operational hours and recommended a firmware patch for land rovers in Greenland to handle low-temperature battery inefficiencies.

You approve the priorities with a voice command, and OptiSynth distributes tasks to your global team, ensuring cohesive collaboration across time zones.

---

7:30 AM CST – Monitoring Team Responsibilities and Data Flow

As you dive into specifics, OptiSynth shifts into team-assistance mode. It’s not just monitoring data—it’s monitoring your people. Each team member, from robotics engineers in Arizona to environmental specialists in Greenland, has a personalized dashboard showing their responsibilities, deadlines, and real-time data feeds relevant to their tasks. OptiSynth uses natural language processing to communicate updates and reminders via voice or text, ensuring no one misses a beat.

For instance, in Arizona, the block cave team receives convergence data showing tunnel strain in real-time. OptiSynth overlays this with fracturing data from draw points, predicting a 12% risk of collapse within 48 hours if extraction rates don’t adjust. It suggests slowing draw rates by 5% and notifying the on-site robotics crew to deploy additional sensors for finer granularity. The team confirms the adjustment, and OptiSynth logs the decision for stakeholder transparency.

Meanwhile, in the Gulf of Mexico, OptiSynth coordinates a fleet of aerial and aquatic drones chasing the oil spill. It optimizes flight paths and submersion patterns to cover the spill’s 20-mile radius efficiently, saving fuel and time. The AI processes multispectral imagery to differentiate oil from water, feeding data into a predictive model that estimates the spill’s spread over the next 72 hours. This saves lives by alerting coastal responders early and saves money by minimizing redundant drone sweeps.

---

9:00 AM CST – Real-Time Stakeholder Interface

Stakeholders—whether mining executives, environmental regulators, or oil company CEOs—need transparency. OptiSynth provides them with a real-time GUI accessible via secure web portals or VR interfaces. This isn’t raw data; it’s processed, visualized, and contextualized. For the Arizona block cave operation, the GUI shows a 3D model of the tunnel network, with color-coded overlays for convergence rates, fracture zones, and air quality metrics like CO2 levels and radioactive background. Stakeholders can zoom into draw points, replay data trends over the past week, or simulate outcomes based on OptiSynth’s predictive models.

In Greenland, the GUI highlights ambient air quality and temperature stressors on equipment in the -40°C environment. OptiSynth has flagged a 2% increase in radioactive background levels (still within safe limits) and suggests a robotic soil sampler investigate a nearby vein. Stakeholders see the data, the recommendation, and the team’s response in real time, fostering trust and informed decision-making.

---

12:00 PM CST – Lunchtime Strategy Session

Over a virtual lunch with your lead engineers, OptiSynth assists by pulling up data on subsurface conditions near an oil rig off Louisiana. Currents have shifted unexpectedly, increasing silting in a canal network feeding New Orleans’ port. OptiSynth proposes deploying underwater drones with sonar to map silt buildup and suggests a dredging schedule that avoids peak shipping hours—all while calculating the cost-benefit ratio. Your team debates adjustments, and OptiSynth records the discussion, updating project timelines and notifying stakeholders of potential delays.

---

2:00 PM CST – Maintenance Updates and Future-Proofing

While you’re on a call with a client in Alaska about pipeline monitoring, OptiSynth handles maintenance in the background. It’s flagged a land drone in Greenland for battery replacement after detecting a 15% efficiency drop in extreme cold. The AI coordinates with the on-site team, scheduling the swap during a low-activity window and ordering parts via an automated supply chain system. Simultaneously, it pushes a software update to sea drones in the Gulf to improve oil detection algorithms based on recent data anomalies.

For future-proofing, OptiSynth analyzes usage patterns across all devices, predicting wear and tear. It suggests upgrading sensors on aerial drones in Arizona to handle dust storms better and recommends a new machine-learning model for pipeline anomaly detection, which could reduce false positives by 8%. You greenlight the upgrades, and OptiSynth handles procurement and deployment timelines.

---

4:00 PM CST – Crisis Management: Oil Spill Escalation

An alert pings: the Gulf oil spill has spread faster than predicted due to a storm surge. OptiSynth instantly recalibrates drone patterns, pulling in additional units from a nearby monitoring operation. It calculates the storm’s impact on dispersion, updates the predictive model, and notifies the Coast Guard with precise coordinates for containment booms. Simultaneously, it briefs your team on the ground, ensuring they prioritize spill mitigation while maintaining safety protocols.

The stakeholder GUI updates in real time, showing the storm’s effect, drone movements, and revised containment timelines. A client texts you, impressed by the speed and clarity of the response—lives are saved because responders acted faster, and costs are contained because resources were allocated efficiently.

---

6:00 PM CST – Wrapping Up and Planning Ahead

As the day winds down, OptiSynth compiles a daily summary: data collected, decisions made, team performance metrics, and stakeholder feedback. It highlights a Greenland team member who exceeded expectations by troubleshooting a robotic sampler mid-blizzard, recommending a bonus. It also flags a potential bottleneck in Arizona—convergence rates are stabilizing, but a new fracturing pattern needs closer monitoring overnight.

OptiSynth then shifts to future planning, suggesting a pilot program for AI-driven subsurface monitoring in the Louisiana bays, using lessons from today’s silting data. It drafts a proposal, complete with cost estimates and ROI projections, for your review tomorrow.

You log off, knowing OptiSynth is still running simulations through the night, updating stakeholders, and ensuring your global fleets are ready for the next day’s challenges.

---

The Ultimate AI Agent: Program-Level Dedication and Features

Dedicated to the Entire Program

Yes, OptiSynth can—and should—be dedicated to the entire program rather than just you. It’s not a personal assistant; it’s a program-level intelligence. It oversees every fleet, every data stream, every team member, and every stakeholder interaction, ensuring nothing slips through the cracks. By centralizing control and analysis, it reduces redundancy, minimizes errors, and maximizes efficiency across air, land, and sea operations.

Assisting Team Cohesion

OptiSynth fosters teamwork by tailoring communication and task management to individual roles while keeping the big picture in focus. It tracks responsibilities, flags delays, and suggests collaborative solutions—like pairing a robotics expert in Arizona with a data analyst in Houston to tackle a convergence issue faster. It also gamifies performance subtly, rewarding high performers with recognition while nudging others to step up, creating a unified, motivated team.

Real-Time Stakeholder GUI

The GUI is a game-changer. It’s customizable per stakeholder—executives get high-level dashboards, engineers see granular data, and regulators get compliance metrics. For block cave operations, it visualizes fracturing, convergence, and air quality in 3D; for oil spills, it maps spread and containment in real time; for Greenland, it tracks radiological data and equipment health. All are processed with specialized software, ensuring stakeholders see actionable insights, not raw numbers.

Handling Diverse Applications

OptiSynth excels across your use cases:

• Block Cave Mining: It predicts tunnel stability, monitors air quality, and tracks radiological risks, adjusting operations to balance safety and productivity.
• Greenland Mining: It optimizes robotics for extreme cold, predicts equipment failures, and monitors environmental impacts like air quality shifts.
• Oil Spill Response: It coordinates drone fleets, predicts spill spread, and minimizes ecological and economic damage.
• Pipeline Monitoring: It detects anomalies, schedules maintenance, and ensures regulatory compliance.
• Subsurface Conditions: It maps currents, silt, and subsurface risks, ensuring safe operations in bays and canals.

Maintenance and Future-Proofing

OptiSynth doesn’t just react—it anticipates. It schedules maintenance based on real-time usage data, pushes software updates to fleets globally, and recommends hardware upgrades to stay ahead of environmental challenges (e.g., better insulation for Greenland drones). It also learns from each operation, refining its models to future-proof your program against evolving risks like climate shifts or regulatory changes.